The ECB Disappoints

Market participants knew that volatility would rise today with the ECB meeting.  What they got was far worse than could have been anticipated. 

Market participants knew that volatility would rise today with the ECB meeting.  What they got was far worse than could have been anticipated. 

It started with a report on the Financial Times a few minutes before the ECB’s official announcement claiming, disappointingly, that there was not rate cut.  The euro took off, spiking to almost $1.07 from around $1.0550.  A few minutes later, the ECB announced the ten bp cut in the deposit rate (to -20 bp).  The euro pulled back but then rallied again to $1.0740 before dropping a cent.  Moreover, all this before Draghi’s press conference began, and the announcement of the QE change details.

Ultimately, and profoundly, the ECB disappointed.  This has rarely been seen in Darghi’s tenure, and hit a market had amassed a significant short euro position over the past several weeks.  As it became clear that the ECB was simply going to deliver the smaller than expected rate cut and extend the program for six months (at least), the shorts ran for what must have felt like a small exit, lifting the euro to almost $1.09.

The ECB announced the inclusion of regional bonds, but the telling disappointment was in not increasing the size of the monthly purchases.  The small tweaks in the staff projections suggest means may keep expectations low for follow-up action in March.  The euro has retraced 38.2% of the decline that began in mid-October.  It is just below $1.09.  The 50% retracement is a little above $1.10.

Relative to market expectations, and what was discounted, the ECB tightened policy. It spurred a sharp backing up of European interest rates and a substantial narrowing of the 2-year interest rate differential that had been widening with the dollar’s rise.

ECB Fireworks is republished with permission from Marc to Market